Malaysia’s Data Center Surge Raises Concerns for Local Businesses and Global Energy Demands
Table of Contents
- Malaysia’s Data Center Surge Raises Concerns for Local Businesses and Global Energy Demands
- Data Center Boom in Johor and Its Far-Reaching Impacts
- Local Concerns and International Comparisons
- Global Rivalry, Policy Shifts, and Future Projections
- Balancing Economic Growth and Resource Sustainability
- Challenges Ahead and Lessons for Global Communities
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What is driving the surge in data centers in Johor?
- How are local businesses impacted by the data center boom?
- What environmental and resource sustainability issues are associated with these data centers?
- What measures are being taken to mitigate these challenges?
- How does Malaysia’s data center expansion compare globally?
Sept. 28, 2024 | Johor Bahru, malaysia
In johor Bahru, a bustling town in Malaysia’s southern state of Johor, local entrepreneur Winson Lau has long relied on a careful balance of water and electricity to power his thriving aquarium export business.Lau, whose operation raises a vivid array of tropical fish – including rare albino varieties with red spots that can command prices up to $10,000 – has established intricate contingency measures. His innovative system purifies wastewater using amiable bacteria and employs an alarm-triggered backup power supply to protect his livelihood against outages.
Yet despite these precautions, Lau now finds himself facing a formidable challenge that he never anticipated: a radical surge in data center growth in his region. As massive,power-intensive data centers are constructed,local energy resources have come under increasing strain,jeopardizing not only high-tech facilities but also small,local businesses like his.
Data Center Boom in Johor and Its Far-Reaching Impacts
Johor is rapidly emerging as Southeast Asia’s fastest-growing data center market. A report published in April revealed that the province is expected to host at least 1.6 gigawatts of data center capacity at any given moment—a figure that has grown from nearly nothing in 2019. As technology giants expand their digital infrastructure to support cloud computing and artificial intelligence, researchers at Malaysia’s Kenanga Investment Bank warn that the demand could surge to more than 5 gigawatts by 2035. This escalation in power usage is significant when one considers that by 2023,Malaysia’s entire renewable capacity barely met half of these projected future needs.
data centers—large, windowless structures filled with rows of computers—rely on energy-intensive cooling systems with pumped water to prevent overheating. Such facilities are critical in running demanding AI systems and offer new opportunities for economic development. however, in this race for digital supremacy, the infrastructure often brings with it complex environmental and societal challenges.
Over 95% of Malaysia’s energy in 2022 came from fossil fuels, and the country has become the world’s fifth-largest exporter of liquefied natural gas. In a recent statement, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim declared that Malaysia was “confident of a surplus of energy” to fuel large projects and sustain export growth. Yet even with optimistic projections, local concerns are mounting.
Local Concerns and International Comparisons
For Lau, the rapid expansion of data centers poses immediate risks. His business has already suffered from power interruptions triggered by severe storms – one incident lasting just 30 minutes devastated 300,000 tropical fish and resulted in losses exceeding $1 million. Fearing that the increased demand from data centers will prolong these outages, Lau is actively exploring relocation options to neighboring Thailand.
“Big data center is coming and ther is shortage of power.It’ll be crazy.”
– Winson Lau
This situation echoes trends seen in other regions. In the United States, as a notable example, data centers are typically built in areas with abundant power resources—such as rural parts of Oregon or upstate New York—but at a high cost due to expensive land and strict environmental regulations. American investors are well aware that even though data centers create a relatively modest number of permanent jobs (30 to 50, with larger facilities peaking at around 200), their energy consumption and resource demands can have significant ripple effects through local communities.
Experts caution that tech companies may be overestimating the transformative benefits of data centers. Sofia Scasserra,a researcher on digital economies at the Amsterdam-based Transnational Institute,compared the resource extraction in the digital realm to “digital colonialism.” She drew a parallel to silver mining in Bolivia, where enormous wealth accrued in the hands of colonial powers, leaving local populations with little benefit. They are extracting data in the same way. Data doesn’t even leave (behind) taxes
, she remarked.
Global Rivalry, Policy Shifts, and Future Projections
The surge in data center investments is not solely about meeting growing digital demands—it is also a frontline in the global competition over artificial intelligence.U.S. policymakers, under President Joe Biden’s governance, recently proposed new regulations aimed at limiting the export of advanced AI chips manufactured by companies like Nvidia. These moves are designed to restrict access to cutting-edge technology among U.S. adversaries such as China, which relies on data centers in Southeast Asia as conduits for AI research. Although the future of these export restrictions remains uncertain,the immediate market reaction was significant,with Chinese competitor GDS Holdings experiencing a stock decline of over 18% on the day of the proclamation.
Investors see Malaysia’s advantages clearly. With inexpensive land, ample power capacity, and attractive tax incentives, Malaysia has become a magnet for foreign investment.According to research by global real estate firm Cushman and Wakefield, in the first half of 2024, Malaysia led the Asia Pacific region as the fastest-growing data center market. Current projections rank Malaysia as the eighth-largest market in operational capacity, with an enterprising roadmap to be among the world’s top 10 markets within five to seven years.Rangu Salgame, chairman and CEO of Singapore’s Princeton Digital Group, pointed out that data centers larger than 40 megawatts require land equivalent to seven football fields—enough to power 36,000 American homes, based on estimates from Stream Data Centers.
Balancing Economic Growth and Resource Sustainability
Despite their promise to modernize the economy and indirectly create thousands of high-paying jobs, data centers also consume vast amounts of resources. Critics argue that while the forecasts for economic growth are bold, the actual transformative impact may fall short in job creation and could rather strain local water and power supplies. The heavy use of water for cooling and the energy demands of these facilities raise red flags, especially in tropical regions like Malaysia where higher ambient temperatures further complicate cooling requirements.
Alex de Vries,founder of Digiconomist—a research firm tracking the environmental repercussions of digital trends—warned,These big tech companies are trying to distract you from the really simple math
. His remarks have resonated with analysts, who view the rapid, unanticipated expansion of data centers as a potential disruptor not only to local businesses but also to regional resource management efforts.
Malaysian officials, though, remain upbeat. Malaysian Investment, Trade and industry Minister Tengku Zafrul Aziz conveyed via email that the government is drafting efficiency guidelines and policies to enable data centers to purchase clean energy directly from producers.He maintained that despite the challenges, Johor’s evolution into a “data center powerhouse” is a cornerstone in Southeast Asia’s burgeoning digital ecosystem.
Challenges Ahead and Lessons for Global Communities
While Malaysia takes center stage in this data center conversion, lessons abound for U.S. policymakers and communities. the U.S. has long navigated similar complexities—in balancing rapid digital expansion with sustainable resource use. American investors and legislators might find valuable insights in Malaysia’s experience as they consider zoning practices, renewable energy investments, and contingency planning for natural disruptions.
Moreover, as climate change intensifies and extreme weather events become more frequent, communities worldwide—whether in the U.S., Malaysia, or other emerging markets—will need to consider the broader implications of energy-intensive infrastructures. Francis Hutchinson, an analyst at Singapore’s ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute, warned that rising population pressures and tourism-related projects could exacerbate regional resource shortages. Water, more than power, is a potential issue
, he observed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is driving the surge in data centers in Johor?
The growth is primarily driven by increasing regional demand for cloud computing and artificial intelligence infrastructure. Johor’s attractive incentives—including inexpensive land, ample power capacity, and favorable tax policies—have positioned it as Southeast Asia’s fastest-growing data centre market.
How are local businesses impacted by the data center boom?
Local businesses, such as Winson Lau’s aquarium export company, are experiencing challenges as the massive, power-intensive data centers strain local energy resources. Concerns include more frequent or prolonged power outages, which directly affect operations and may force some businesses too consider relocation.
What environmental and resource sustainability issues are associated with these data centers?
Data centers require significant amounts of energy and water, which raises concerns about resource sustainability. With over 95% of Malaysia’s energy coming from fossil fuels and limited renewable capacity, the additional demand from these centers can exacerbate issues related to water usage for cooling and overall power strain in tropical regions.
What measures are being taken to mitigate these challenges?
Local authorities are drafting efficiency guidelines and policies that would allow data centers to directly purchase clean energy from producers. Businesses like Winson Lau’s are also implementing contingency measures, such as backup power supplies, while exploring potential relocation to reduce the impacts of power interruptions.
How does Malaysia’s data center expansion compare globally?
Malaysia’s rapid development in data centers contrasts with practices in other parts of the world, such as the U.S., where facilities are typically built in regions with abundant power but at high land and regulatory costs. This expansion is a significant aspect of the global competition over digital infrastructure and artificial intelligence research.