The allure of ornately packaged, heavily advertised shampoos promising to solve all hair woes often prompts a question: are the higher price tags justified? Should consumers abandon their $8 shampoo for a $42 alternative?
Experts suggest that affordable shampoos and conditioners found in supermarkets and drugstores can perform just as effectively as their more expensive counterparts, despite enticing marketing and social media endorsements. They advise consumers to evaluate product ingredients, their specific hair and scalp concerns, and their hair care routine, and to consult a physician when in doubt.
Whereas premium brands can deliver results, and some utilize more costly active ingredients, dermatologists note that factors like company size and investments in sustainable practices – including eco-friendly ingredients, sustainable agriculture, and recycled materials – also contribute to price differences.
Understanding Your Hair Type
Dr. Crystal Aguh, a dermatologist and director of the Ethnic Skin Program at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, typically categorizes individuals based on whether their hair is prone to damage or resistant to it.
Those prone to damage include individuals with highly textured curls, chemically treated hair, and those who frequently use heat styling tools. Conversely, oily and straight hair types are generally more resistant to damage.
For those with damage-prone hair, Aguh recommends avoiding shampoos where sodium lauryl sulfate is the primary ingredient. This ingredient strips away sebum, a natural oil that coats and protects the hair. Without sebum, hair becomes dry and prone to breakage.
Individuals with curly or color-treated hair should wash their hair less frequently to avoid stripping away too much sebum. Those with very curly or thick hair should wash it once a week, while those with wavy and color-treated hair should wash it every two to three days.
Oily and damage-resistant hair types can generally be washed daily.
Focus on the Process, Not Just the Products
Expensive shampoos and conditioners can yield good results, but equally effective affordable options are available, according to Aguh. She tells patients that “it’s not the products, it’s the process” that most significantly impacts hair health, including washing frequency, coloring, and heat treatment.
“Instead of spending hundreds of dollars thinking, ‘If I find the right shampoo, the right conditioner, all my problems will go away,’ you also have to appear at what your process is like… because that often will do the trick,” she said.
She added that mixing high-end and mass-market products is acceptable, and consumers shouldn’t feel pressured to purchase an entire line of expensive products.
Aguh explained that some common brands are more affordable because they are manufactured by large companies that can achieve economies of scale. More expensive brands sometimes have smaller teams and lack the workforce and resources to achieve the same cost advantages.
For dandruff treatment, for example, Aguh often recommends over-the-counter shampoos rather than prescription formulas. Though, she advises seeking medical attention for persistent dandruff issues.
Shampoo as Scalp Care
Dr. Joe Tung, a dermatologist at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, emphasizes that shampoo should be considered a scalp care product, not merely a cosmetic one.
“The hair itself is biologically inactive once it grows, but beneath the skin’s surface of the scalp is a complete ecosystem with stem cells, immune cells, sebaceous glands, and nerve endings,” he explains. “When that ecosystem is balanced, the scalp feels comfortable and hair grows optimally; when disrupted, people can experience itchiness, flaking, excess oil, or hair loss.”
Tung advises considering scalp needs when choosing a shampoo, and selecting a conditioner based on hair texture and degree of damage. He notes that dandruff and itchiness benefit from shampoos that combat inflammation and microbial imbalance, while dry or chemically treated hair may benefit from a gentle cleanser with a rich conditioner.
According to Tung, expensive shampoos and conditioners are sometimes worth the cost, but a product’s effectiveness is determined by its active ingredients, not the brand name. “An antifungal ingredient works by its molecular activity, not because it comes in a luxury bottle or from a prestigious brand,” he said.
More expensive shampoos often utilize more refined conditioning agents and soothing ingredients that can make frequent hair washing more comfortable, Tung added. However, some luxury products contain fragrances or botanical extracts that can irritate sensitive skin, and individuals with sensitive skin may tolerate simpler formulas better.
Hair Care with a Sustainable Focus
MOKO Organic Beauty Studio, based in Philadelphia, offers organic shampoos and conditioners priced between $24 and $45. Owner Monique Mason says the salon’s mission is to provide products that are good for both the scalp and the planet.
Ingredients are the biggest factor influencing price, Mason said. Organic products generally avoid low-cost sulfates, synthetic fragrances, and parabens commonly used in the personal care industry. Mason also researches how brands manufacture their products to ensure sustainability claims can be verified.
“I get to know them, if they’re family-owned, how they grow, how they source their ingredients,” she explains.
___
This story was translated from English to Spanish using an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
