Kim Kardashian has clarified the origin of a controversial Birkin bag seen in photos from November, revealing it was a counterfeit prop used during filming of her Hulu series, “All’s Fair.” The bag, which appeared to be made of elephant skin, sparked widespread criticism online, with many questioning the ethics of using such a material.
Kardashian addressed the controversy on her sister Khloé Kardashian’s podcast, “Khloé in Wonder Land,” stating the accessory was not authentic. “If you seem at it… the hardware is upside down… it’s like an actual full fake one,” she explained. The incident highlights the increasing scrutiny celebrities face regarding their fashion choices and the sourcing of luxury goods.
The reality star-turned-actress had been photographed carrying the gray Hermès bag on the set of “All’s Fair” and in behind-the-scenes images shared by her stylist, Soki Mak. The bag was selected simply because it matched her outfit in a scene where her character, Allura Grant, wore all gray. Kardashian admitted she wished she had been “a little bit smarter” about using the prop, regardless of its authenticity.
The controversy drew criticism from other public figures, including Ireland Baldwin, who called the bag “disgusting and shameful” in an Instagram story. The incident underscores the growing consumer awareness of ethical sourcing and sustainability within the luxury fashion industry.
Zurich Leather Artisan Disputes Claim
Peter Nitz, a leather artisan based in Zurich, has publicly challenged Kardashian’s claim, asserting the bag was, in fact, authentic. In a video posted to Instagram, Nitz stated he previously owned a similar Birkin bag made of elephant leather. “When I first saw photos of Kim with the elephant skin Birkin, I thought, ‘Oh wow, it’s lovely.’ I had a similar bag,” he said.
Nitz, who now runs his own brand, Peter Nitz, previously worked as a reseller of luxury handbags. In 2013, he sold a rare elephant skin Birkin to a client in Zurich. He believes Kardashian’s bag is the same one.
Nitz points to the unique grain of elephant skin, which he says is comparable to a fingerprint, allowing for reliable comparisons. After examining images, he believes the bags are identical, noting matching creases and even a tiny black spot. “You can position the photos of Kim’s bag and mine side by side and see that they are the same,” he stated.
Peter Nitz too uses exotic leather for his bags
Peter Nitz’s own brand also features products made with exotic leathers. He personally selects alligator, crocodile, ostrich, and lizard skins – all sourced ethically, according to the company. His website currently lists a gray elephant skin “Micro Dream Bag” for 2000 Swiss Francs, though We see currently sold out.
Nitz also noted the reversed hardware as another clue, explaining that early Birkin bags featured incorrectly mounted hooks. The debate highlights the complexities of sourcing materials in the luxury goods market and the challenges of verifying authenticity.
